Raymar Nick
Certainly! The concept of a „regelbasierte Ordnung“ (rules-based order) has been a topic of discussion in international relations, particularly in Western countries. However, it lacks a clear and universally agreed-upon definition. Let’s explore this concept further:
- Definition and Context:
- The term „regelbasierte Ordnung“ refers to both legally binding norms of international law and non-binding norms, standards, and behavioral rules.
- It encompasses a range of concepts without a precise definition.
- Different countries interpret it differently, leading to varying meanings and applications.
- Some states reject this term altogether, preferring to rely solely on established international law (Völkerrecht) as the legal framework for global governance.
- United Nations (UN):
- UN Secretary-General António Guterres highlighted the threat to multilateralism in 2018, emphasizing the need for a renewed commitment to a rules-based order.
- He called for institutions like the UN to play a central role in upholding this order through treaties and agreements.
- Germany’s Perspective:
- Germany uses the concept of a rules-based order as both a political term and a legal framework.
- It includes legally binding rules from international law (Völkerrecht) as well as informal norms, standards, and cooperative behavior.
- Examples include timely payment of contributions, multilateral cooperation for a cooperative world order, and participation in international forums with their decision-making processes.
- Other Components:
- Besides the UN and international law, Germany also considers the Agenda 2030 (UN), G7, G20, NATO, OSCE, and the Council of Europe as part of the rules-based order.
- Criticism and Challenges:
- Critics argue that Germany’s portrayal as a champion of the rules-based order is hypocritical.
- While advocating for rules externally, Germany has faced more EU treaty violation procedures than some other member states.
- The tension arises when Germany’s actions don’t align with its rhetoric, leading partners to perceive self-righteousness.
In summary, the concept of a rules-based order remains multifaceted and context-dependent. It combines legal norms with cooperative behavior but faces challenges related to consistency and perception. Germany’s commitment to this order reflects its pursuit of stability and cooperation on the global stage [^2^
Kommentar verfassen